Pilot Study on Problem Oriented and Student Centered Teaching of Physiology in A Large Class Setting
Abstract
Recent developments in undergraduate medical
education have shifted the focus from a knowledge-based
curriculum to one where problem solving and reasoning skills are
paramount. Such skills are best developed by active problem
solving exercises. The constraints of active learning in a
physiology class are stressed because many students take the
course. A technique that can be used in such situations was
developed in our school. The tutor designed problems with
instructional objectives. Students were instructed to group
themselves into small physiology teams. Teams selected
particularly problems from the mini-library of cases. They were
guided to approach the problem systematically through the
search for relevant materials, consultation with the faculty and
visits of practical sites. After the exploration of the scenarios
whole class presentations followed. Students who participated in
the program evaluated the problem oriented approach. Results
are generally favorable; students felt that the learning became
meaningful and improved their ability to solve problems. This
study has demonstrated that active student-centered teaching
can be employed in large class settings. However, a change in
learning methods requires a concomitant change in assessment
systems.
Downloads
References
Twenty-first Century. Report of the panel on the General Professional
Education of the Physician and the College Preparation of Medicine.
Washington DC.
Abbatt F. (1992). Teaching for Better Learning; A Guide for Teachers of
Primary Health Care Staff, 2nd ed. Geneva, WHO
Abrahma Husain (1996). Child learing Practice in Siltigna-Speaking
Community: Impact on the Development of Independence and social
Responsibility. In Habtamu Wendimu, Research Papers on he
Situation of Children and Adolescents in Ethiopia. PP. 137 - 47.
Addis Ababa: AAU printing press.
Ayele Meshesha (1996). Conflict Between Modern Education and Cultural
and Institutional Values in Ethiopia: Can it ever be resolved? In
Habtamu Wendimu, Research Papers on the Situation of Children
and Adolescents in Ethiopia. Pp. 229-42 Addis Ababa: Addis
Ababa University Printing Press:
Caglayan, S. (1994). Effectiveness of an Active Method in Teaching
Physiology. American Journal of Physiology (Adv Physiology Educ.
12},267:S81 -S86.
Cliff, H. and Wright A. (1996). Direct case Study Method for Teaching
Human Anatomy and Physiology. American Journal of Physiology (Adv Physiol Educ 19), 270:S19-S28
Cox, D. (1967). The Adolescent in Ethiopia. The Ethiopian Journal of
Education 1
Engelberg, J. (1992). Complex Medical Case Histories as Portals to Medical
Practice and Integrative Scientific Thought. American Journal of
Physiology, 263: S48-S54.
GMC (General Medical Council Educational Committee) (1993) Tomorrow's
Doctors: Recommendations on Undergraduate Medical
Education, UK.
Herreid, CF. (1994). Case Studies in Science: A Novel Method of Science
Education. J Coli Sci Teach, 23:221-229.
Margaret, P Chandler & Decarlo, S. (1994). An Educational Tool for
Understanding the Cardiopulmonary Changes Associated with Aging.
Advances in Physiology Education, 12,1 :S17-S36.
Maslow, A (1971). The Farther Reaches of Human Nature. Harmondsworth:
Penguine.
Ministry of Education (MOE}/Report of a task force (1997). Higher Education
and Training on Health in Ethiopia, February 20-22, 1997, Addis
Ababa, Ethiopia.
Modell, H. & Michael J. (1993). Promoting Active Learning in the Life Science
Classroom. Annuals of the New York Academy of Sciences,
701 :1-7.
Quinn, F. (1988). The Principles and Practice of Nurse Education,
2nd ed., Chapman & Hall.
Reagan, C. & Menninger RP (1994). Ten Years of Basic Medical Physiology
in the Mercer Problem-based Curriculum. American Journal of
Physiology (Adv Physiol Educ. 11), 266:S24-S32.
Richardson, D. & Bridge, B. (1995). Teaching Physiology by Combined
Passive (pedagogical) and active (andragogical) Methods. American
Journal of Physiology, 268:S66-S74.
Somjen, G. (1990). Teaching Physiology in Developing Countries: Report of a
Meeting. News in Physiological Sciences, 5:269
Sukker, M. (1984). An Approach to the Question of Relevance of Medical Physiology Courses. Medical Education 18:217 - 221 .