Performance of Freshman and Preparatory Origin Students on a Reading Comprehension Test: A Comparative Study
Abstract
Following the country’s higher education reform, institutions of higher learning in the country, during the 2003/2004 academic year, had to admit two groups of students – the freshman origin and the preparatory origin – to departments in their faculties. This study which was carried out during the said academic year involved two freshman and two preparatory sections/classes, one each from the Departments of Foreign Languages and Literature and, Ethiopian Languages and Literature, Institute of Language Studies, Addis Ababa University.
The purpose was to investigate if there exist differences in the reading comprehension performance of the groups. Participants were selected on availability basis as these were the only groups newly admitted to the Departments during that academic year. All sat for a reading comprehension test and an independent samples t-test was applied on the scores. Results showed that freshman origin students performed significantly higher than their preparatory counter parts. This might imply that despite the heavy responsibility laid on the shoulders of preparatory schools in the various regions in preparing their students for the demands that higher education would put to them, it seems there is still a lot expected of them to bridge existing gaps. Therefore, that the schools and other relevant bodies work harder to alleviate the problem seems to be in order.
Downloads
References
Experience and the Emerging Ethiopian Response. The Ethiopian Journal
of Higher Education, I, 1:21-40
Burns, P. C., B. D., Roe, and E. P. Ross (1999). Teaching Reading in Today’s
Elementary Schools (7th Edition). Boston: Haughton, Mifflin Company
Carrell, P. L., J. Devine and D. E. Eskey (eds.) (1988). Interactive Approaches to
Second Language Reading. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Clapham, M. C. (1996) The Development of IELTS: A Study of the Effect of
Background Knowledge on Reading Comprehension. Cambridge:CUP
Clarke, M. A. (1980) The Short Circuit Hypothesis of ESL Reading – or When
Language Competence Interferes with Reading Performance. Reprinted in P.
L. Carrell, J. Devine and D. E. Eskey (eds.) pp. 114 - 124
Devine, J. (1987) General Language Competence and Adult Second Language
Reading. In J. Devine, P. L. Carrell, and D. E. Eskey (eds.) pp. 73-87
_____ (1988) The Relationship between General Language Competence and
Second Language Reading Proficiency: Implications for Teaching. In P. L.
Carrell, J. Devine and D. E. Eskey (eds.), pp. 260-277
Devine, J., P. L. Carrell and D. E. Eskey (eds.) (1987) Research in Reading in
English as a Second Language. Washington D. C.: TESOL
Gebenedio, U. B. (1986) Two Methods of Teaching Reading in Nigerian Primary
Classes, ELT Journal 40, 1:46-51
Harri-Augustein, S., M. Smith, and L. Thomas (1982) Reading to Learn. Methuen
and Co. Ltd.
Main, A. (1980). Encouraging Effective Learning. Scottish Academic Press
Ridgway, T. (1997). Thresholds of the Background Knowledge Effect in Foreign
Language Reading. Reading in a Foreign Language, 11, 1:151-166
Ruddel (1997). Teaching Content Reading and Writing. Boston: Allyn and Bacon Taye Regassa (1988) A Proposal to Conduct a Pre-sessional Study Skills
Course in Reading to Assist the One-Year Trainee Teachers in the
Ethiopian Teachers’ Training Institutes. (Unpublished M.A. Thesis) Moray
House College of Education, Edinburgh
_____ (2000). The Effect of Academic Background on Reading Comprehension:
The Case of First-Year Students at the College of Social Sciences, Addis
Ababa University. Proceedings of the 12th Annual Conference of the Institute
of Language Studies. pp. 1-12
_____ (2004). Freshman and Preparatory Complete Students: Do They Exhibit
Difference in Their reading Achievement? Paper presented at the IER Annual
Conference, 15 -16 October 2004, Addis Ababa
Teshome Yizengaw (2004) The Status and Challenges of Ethiopian Higher
Education System and Its Contribution to Development. The Ethiopian
Journal of Higher Education, I, 1:1-19
Yorkey, R. C. (1970). Study Skills for Students of English as a Second
Language. New York: McGraw Hill.